Site Meter Watching Doctor Who » Blog Archive » Review: The Unquiet Dead (9th Doctor)

Review: The Unquiet Dead (9th Doctor)

by Elisa

unquietdead.jpg

The Unquiet Dead - Episode 1.3

The Unquiet Dead is the first episode written by someone other than Russell T. Davies. Mark Gatiss gives us Rose’s first trip into the past. This is a bit of a seasonal episode. Yes, I do want Rose’s dress. How did you guess? Let’s get to the spoilery stuff.

Episode: The Unquiet Dead by Mark Gatiss
Rating (1 to 5): 3
Baddie: The Gelth
Rose is Trapped: In a locked room with Zombies. And in the basement with Zombies.
The Doctor is Trapped: in the basement with Zombies.
The Doctor Enjoys: Charles Dickens and Happy Mediums
The Doctor Dislikes: the American bit in Martin Chuzzlewit
Doctor-y Strangeness: his willingness to let the Gelth use dead bodies to live in.
Scary Stuff: The Gelth killing people in order to use their bodies.
Does someone local help out? Charles Dickens, Gwyneth, and Mr. Sneed.
Bad Wolf? Gwyneth sees it in Rose’s mind.
What we learn: The TARDIS still has a wardrobe room. The Doctor likes his tea with two sugars. There’s a spacial-temporal rift in Cardiff. Time’s in flux and it is not a straight line. It can twist into any shape. The books of Charles Dickens survive forever. Rose’s father is dead.
The Doctor’s Death Wish: The Doctor tries to get Gwyneth to let him blow up the house.
The Doctor Apologizes To: Dickens (for telling him to Shut Up) & Gwyneth
My Favorite Bits: The Doctor kicking open the door to save Rose. “What the Shakespeare is going on?” The Doctor’s love of Charles Dickens books. Rose’s dress.

Observations and musings:

Rose arrives in Victorian Cardiff for her first trip backwards in time. She has her first encounter with the wardrobe room, and I think that The Doctor was a bit startled by her appearance. Of course, he only changed his jumper, and he’s the one that made her change! Did he really have to add, “for a human”? Rose is intrigued by The Doctor’s ability to go back and see days that are dead and gone, and this time she gets to make the first step into the unknown. She doesn’t hold with his idea of letting the Gelth use the bodies of dead humans, or his plan to have Gwyneth help the Gelth arrive. It turns out that he should have listened to her, shouldn’t he?

The Doctor aimed to take Rose to Naples on Christmas Eve 1860. Instead, they landed in Cardiff on Christmas Eve 1869. Luckily, Rose is unfazed by his getting the flight a bit wrong, beacuse she will soon discover that this is a common occurence. Did you catch the small smile he had on his face after the “for a human” line? The Doctor is so very willing to believe that the Gelth need his help, especially once they tell him that their problems stem from the Time War. He won’t listen to Rose’s objections. (Well, not much anyway.) He sees the solution to a problem, and he wants the satisfaction of solving it. Too bad he’d never encountered the Gelth before.

Charles Dickens in Cardiff fighting ghostly aliens with Rose and The Doctor, only to be saved in the end by a psychic servant girl who was already dead? Yep, that about sums it up. Eve Myles who plays Gwyneth in this episode also plays Gwen on Torchwood. Torchwood also takes place in Cardiff and has to do with the Rift. Interesting parallels, eh? Charles Dickens certainly enjoys his adventure with The Doctor in the end. Simon Callow, who portrays Dickens in this episode, represented a bit of a casting coup for the Doctor Who team. He is well known for his previous portrayals of Mr. Dickens. So, it was a bit like really having Dickens on the set, apparently. Tune in next Saturday for my review of “Aliens of London.”

, , , , ,

Image Source: http://www.time-and-space.co.uk/


One Response to “Review: The Unquiet Dead (9th Doctor)”

  1. Watching Doctor Who » Blog Archive » Another Week in the Whoniverse Says:

    [...] Who Confidential - 3:00am - 3:15am - BBC Three Doctor Who - 7:00pm - 7:45pm – The Unquiet Dead - BBC Three Doctor Who Confidential - 7:45pm - 8:00pm - BBC [...]

Leave a Reply


About Watching Doctor Who

Watching Doctor Who is a tale of obsession, an epic story of love and loss, a saga that spans time and space…Well, actually, it’s a blog that covers everything that has to do with the television show Doctor Who and its spin-offs. From news to videos and reviews to questions, you’ll find it here…and that other stuff, too.

Watching Doctor Who Author(s)
    » Elisa

TV Channel Posts

  • Mad Men: "The Inheritance"
    We mentioned on Friday that Mad Men last Sunday, along with the Entourage episode on the same night seemed a little off-beat to what we are accustom too from both series. The difference being the [...]
  • The He in the She - last new episode for a while...
    Let me start by saying... wow. I'm impressed. I'm going to have to give this a little more thought - there was a lot of really interesting points brought up in this episode, and there was so much [...]
  • Heroes Roundup for 10.11.08
    Digital Spy has a short article about Jack Coleman in which he talks about his horn-rimmed glasses: "My character was called Horn-Rimmed Glasses from the start," Coleman told Radio Times. [...]
  • Promo Images from Episode 3.07, “Eris Quod Sum”
    Here are several images from episode 3.07, “Eris Quod Sum.”  Kristen Bell fans will be pleased to see that she is back. Looks like we’ll be seeing a big fight between Elle and the [...]
  • Promo Images from Episode 3.06, “Dying of the Light”
    Here are 3 images from episode 3.06, "Dying of the Light." They show villains Adam Monroe and Knox visiting Arthur Petrelli's bedside. Does that mean the promo that shows Arthur meeting [...]
  • More Promotional Images from Episode 3.05, “Angels and Monsters”
    NBC has been busy releasing promo images for episodes 5, 6, and 7.  In this set, from episode 5, “Angels and Monsters,” we get our first look at villain Stephen Canfield, known as Vortex, as [...]
  • CMT’s Reality Shows
    It looks like CMT is in the Reality TV show business too. CMT’s two hit shows My Big Redneck Wedding and Dallas Cowboy Cheerleaders: Making The Team both returned last Saturday. My Big Redneck [...]
  • CMT’s Reality Shows
    It looks like CMT is in the Reality TV show business too. CMT’s two hit shows My Big Redneck Wedding and Dallas Cowboy Cheerleaders: Making The Team both returned last Saturday. My Big Redneck [...]
  • Emily Deschanel in Statement Magazine
    GREAT shot of Emily Deschanel from the "Green Issue" of Statement Magazine. I love the caption - considering how we all know how active Emily is in different environmental and animal rights causes. [...]
  • Rebecca Mader in George Clooney Movie
    Lost co-star, Rebecca Mader, is joining George Clooney's latest project, Men Who Stare at Goats. Rebecca will play one of George's leading lady and will be part of an ensemble cast that includes [...]

Hot Off The Press