Site Meter Watching Doctor Who » Blog Archive » Review: Doomsday (10th Doctor)

Review: Doomsday (10th Doctor)

by Elisa

doomsday2.jpg

Doomsday - Episode 2.13

This is the last episode of season two. Interesting to note that as shown on the Sci Fi Channel, there were a few tiny pieces missing. Seconds and interesting lines were shaved off of scenes. Luckily, the DVD set for this season comes out in a couple of weeks. I love this episode, and wow did it hurt me the first time through. (Okay, it actually hurts me every time.) All hail Russell T. Davies for the script and Murray Gold for the incredible music. Okay, let’s gets to the spoilers.

Episode: Doomsday
Rating (1 to 5): 5
Baddie: Cybermen & Daleks! (luckily not as allies)
Rose is trapped: In another reality. That is pretty final. (sob.)
The Doctor is trapped: here without Rose in the end. Before that he is briefly trapped in Pete’s World. He was a prisoner of the Cybermen for a little bit before that, even.
The Doctor enjoys: The emotion of Hope and the phrase “via the void.”
The Doctor dislikes: Losing Rose. He burns up a Sun to say goodbye. (He also dislikes Daleks and Cybermen)
Doctor-y Strangeness: The 3-D glasses. The Doctor as an inter-reality matchmaker?
Scary Stuff: Cybermen & Daleks!?!? The Void.
Does someone local help out? Cyber-Yvonne.
What we learn: Kill one Cyberleader and they just download into another. The parallel Torchwood is under the control of the People’s Government. Harriet Jones is President in Pete’s World. The Time Lords built the Genesis Ark. It’s a prison ship that is bigger on the inside. Every time you travel from one reality to another you rip a hole in the universe. The Doctor fought on the front lines of the Time War, and he was there at the fall of Arcadia. When you travel in time you soak up background radiation.
My Favorite Bits: “Oh, do some reasearch. We don’t have a central world authority.” The Daleks and The Cybermen taunting each other. Jackie and Pete’s first interaction. The name of Bad Wolf bay. The Doctor and Rose on either side of the white wall, and the fact that they seem to be able to sense each other. The scene on the beach.

Observations and musings:

Well, this is it. The end of Rose’s story arc. Look how far she’s come. Seriously, go back and watch Rose. See the difference? She has experience to go along with her adaptability and her slightly unusual thought process. And she did sort of die in battle. See, the baddie from The Satan Pit was telling another half-truth. I was interested to see how she took charge of the Dalek situation. Once she saw who was leaving the sphere, she moved right on to the problem of the Genesis Arc. She didn’t waste time wondering why they were alive. I was also glad to know that she remembers what she did to the Emperor. Her mother was right it seems. She has changed. Rose has grown up. Trapped in another reality from The Doctor she loves, she got a job at Torchwood. She’s still defending the Earth

Dear heavens, the poor Doctor. He tries to send Rose away again. How well did that work last time, eh? Let’s see, last time she came back, saved your life, and you ended up having to regenerate. I’m thinking that The Doctor should have realized that it wasn’t going to be that easy. ( I wonder if she would have been safe in the TARDIS?) You could see how much it cost him to make the decision to send her away, but he did it anyway. Then when he was walking away from the White Wall, he looked seriously shell-shocked. At least Rose didn’t fall into the void. Who knows what he would have been like then? I would like to take this moment to point out that he found the last hole in reality and burned up a sun to say good-bye, and yet he still has the problem that he had during The Satan Pit. He couldn’t say it. He missed his only chance to tell Rose that he loved her back. He waited just a bit too long. (And wasn’t his face a study for the two seconds that he thought she might be pregnant?) I wonder what he will be like with his one stabilizing influence gone?

I am unable to be objective about Doomsday. This episode destroyed me the first time I saw it. I couldn’t sleep afterwards. Seriously. It really got to me. I’ve seen it several times, and every time I still cry. Maybe it’s the music at the beach, which is currently stuck in my head. I’m not sure. Perhaps it is the sheer visceral emotion of the episode. Reunion, Loss, Death, Sorrow, Heartbreak, and Anger, Doomsday has it all. All of that and the fall of Torchwood one. Poor Rose can’t even visit Sarah Jane. (FYI, for little bits and pieces that have been cut out for the American version, you may want to watch the the DVDs. For example, the Doctor isn’t angry with Mickey for touching the Genesis Ark.)

Well, this is it for new episodes in the USA until the Summer. There is another Sci Fi Channel marathon on the 12th, and BBC America continues it’s showings of Doctor Who Season one. So, next Saturday I will post my review for The Unquiet Dead and move forward from there. Have a Happy New Year!

Image Source: http://www.time-and-space.co.uk/

, , ,


8 Responses to “Review: Doomsday (10th Doctor)”

  1. Emily Says:

    So I know I’m a little late, but I finally watched the finale.
    I cried.
    And I really really miss Rose.
    I can’t stop thinking about it.
    I know its just a tv show, but damn if it doesn’t hurt me inside.
    Meh.

  2. Elisa Says:

    Emily, that episode kills me. It still does, actually. I’m thinking that’s half the reason I am attempting to write a bit of fanfiction. You should have seen me the first time I saw that ending. I was…distraught. Do you have a copy of The Runaway Bride (Christmas special)?

  3. Nan Says:

    Why did they do that? Dis she quite. I hated every minute.

  4. Elisa Says:

    Why did they do what, Nan? Have Rose leave? Apparently, she wanted to leave before she got too afraid to do so. I miss her already.

  5. doctor doctor Says:

    what was tht music? when the doctor leaves rose.

  6. Elisa Says:

    Doctor doctor, it’s on the soundtrack, and it’s called: “Doomsday.”
    My post about the soundtrack: http://www.watchingdrwho.com/review-doctor-who-the-original-television-soundtrack/
    I ordered it from Amazon.co.uk

  7. Pop Buzz UK » Blog Archive » Billie Piper To Return To Doctor Who? | Will She Reprise Role As Rose Alongside David Tennant? Says:

    [...] left at the end of season 2 where in an episode entitled Doomsday she was confined to a parallel universe along with her mum, deceased dad and boyfriend Mickey. The [...]

  8. Pop Buzz UK » Blog Archive » ‘The Golden Compass’ Author Philip Pullman Keen To Write ‘Doctor Who’ Episode & Praises Show Says:

    [...] also affirmed his belief that Doomsday, the second season finale, contains material similar to his own work saying: “I was [...]


About Watching Doctor Who

Watching Doctor Who is a tale of obsession, an epic story of love and loss, a saga that spans time and space…Well, actually, it’s a blog that covers everything that has to do with the television show Doctor Who and its spin-offs. From news to videos and reviews to questions, you’ll find it here…and that other stuff, too.

Watching Doctor Who Author(s)

TV Channel Posts

  • Emily supports HR 1326 (chimps)
    We all know and love that Emily Deschanel is very active in the rights of animals. She's known for being a vegetarian, and has supported various causes over the years. Now, she's written to [...]
  • Emily as Dr. Farquad
    Saw the movie My Sister's Keeper last night - I left the theatre with mixed feelings. The film was beautifully done, and I say that after watching it with skepticism. I pretty much knew the storyline [...]
  • A Special Surprise: Interview with Ronnie's Wife!
    As the links to various MySpaces were found and dug up on the 1st after the cast reveal, I jumped at the chance to message Ronnie's wife, and see what she'd like all of us to know about the Gamer [...]
  • Reality Wanted Interviews!
    They'll go right here as they come in! First up - Jeff! [...]
  • Interviews are going up!
    At long last! We have interviews going up at CBS2! So check it out here, as Diane interviews. It's hard to hear Diane, as usual, so up your volume a bit! (I'm sure someone will youtube them too - [...]
  • Retcon Patrol: 2-05 "Domestic Issues" Part 5
    Today we continue our look for inconsistent or comment-worthy moments in the Brothers & Sisters second season with a look at the final part of Episode 5. Read Part 1, 2 3, and 4, and then hop right [...]
  • Independence Day Weekend Links
    Few notes before we get to the links. First off, we're not going to be posting twice today like we suggested yesterday. For whatever reason, it alluded us that this is 4th of July weekend and we have [...]
  • Clip of the Week
    This week's clip comes from Guiding Light. It is a clip from the Bauer BBQ of Danny and Michelle getting married. [...]
  • Happy Birthday, Thomas Gibson!
    Here's a picture of Thomas Gibson looking all smiley, which I thought was appropriate for his birthday. Wish Thomas the best, and have a happy Third and Fourth of July! Have a safe weekend and [...]
  • Ross Interviews the Women of Big Brother!
    Here you go! YAY ROSS! [...]

Hot Off The Press

  • Don't ask if you don't want to hear the answer!
    I have a new mantra: If you don't want to hear the answer, don't ask the question. All of us have asked those innocent little questions, like "Do these pants make me look fat?" or "Is she [...]
  • Happy Independence Day!
    July 4th is here and I'd like to wish all my readers in the United States happy Independence Day, because it is America's birthday today. For the rest of you, I guess you can just sit on it. For [...]
  • Happy 4th of July
    I know that unless you are in the mood to run around like a crazy woman, the tips here may not be very helpful.  But, at the same time, some of you might like to employ some of the ides here on [...]
  • Emily supports HR 1326 (chimps)
    We all know and love that Emily Deschanel is very active in the rights of animals. She's known for being a vegetarian, and has supported various causes over the years. Now, she's written to [...]
  • Nicole Richie’s Maternity Collection out this summer
    For a fashion icon and mother-to-be (for the second time) like Nicole Richie, coming up with a maternity collection is something that fans have always anticipated. Why even while still [...]
  • Raw in Auckland, McCool Photos, "Million Dollar" Profiled
    -World Wrestling Entertainment has kicked off this week-end in Auckland, New Zealand. You an see photos of the the Raw roster for the event on WWE.com. -Michelle McCool has new photos in her ecent [...]
  • Call for Submissions: Warren Alder Short Story Contest
    Spring/Summer 2009 Contest Theme: Short Fiction in Varied Genres Submit Your Stories Now! The Warren Adler Short Story Contest is fast becoming the most prestigious online short [...]
  • To Clean Up A Bit ...
    Okay ... normally I'd be jawjackin' about the latest happenings or doohickies in rock music, right? But, y'know, sometimes yer PC just doesn't wanna behave when you're doin' the Last Writes [...]
  • Emily as Dr. Farquad
    Saw the movie My Sister's Keeper last night - I left the theatre with mixed feelings. The film was beautifully done, and I say that after watching it with skepticism. I pretty much knew the storyline [...]
  • Not worth the paper they aren't signed on
    First of all, if you are reading this on the Fourth of July... well, you need to get outside and grill some burgers! Now, in the meantime: Every day my inbox is flooded with announcements [...]