Site Meter Watching Doctor Who » Blog Archive » Review: Daleks in Manhattan (10th Doctor)

Review: Daleks in Manhattan (10th Doctor)

by

daleksinmanhattan1.jpg

Daleks in Manhattan - Episode 3.4

Daleks in Manhattan is part one of a two. The title itself could be considered a spoiler, really, as it tells you where the episode takes place and who the baddies are. I can’t say too much more here except that I enjoyed the variety of American accents that they came up with, and did you know that the guy who plays Solomon was in the first Highlander film? Right then, on to the review!

Episode: Daleks in Manhattan by Helen Raynor
Rating (1 to 5): 3
Time: November 1, 1930
Place: Manhattan (New York)
Baddie: Daleks, Mr. Diagoras
The Doctor’s Death Wish: He tries to send Martha and Frank away with Solomon so that he can go on alone in the tunnels.
The Doctor enjoys: The cold Atlantic breeze.
The Doctor dislikes: Daleks and their tendency to survive.
The Doctor apologizes to: a pig slave in the tunnels
Rose? Is she the Everything that The Doctor lost this time around?
Who fancies Martha? Frank
Doctor-y Strangeness: He picks up a glowing ting that they find in the sewers…and sniffs it. And then apparently puts it in his pocket. Then he rigs up a crude DNA scanner from stuff that he finds backstage.
Scary Stuff: Humanoid attack pigs!
Does someone local help out? Solomon, Frank, Tallulah, and Laszlo.
What we learn: The Empire State Building wasn’t quite done in November of 1930. After the Wall Street crash, folks with nowhere else to go, created a Hooverville in Central Park. The Daleks are behind the construction of The Empire State building in some way. Dalekanium is attached to the mast at the top of the building. Dalek Sec is the leader of the Cult of Skaro. The thing that The Doctor found in the tunnels was artificially created. Fundamental DNA type 467-989 originates from Skaro. Frank and Martha have “Superior Intelligence.” Dalek Sec has decided the the Daleks need to evolve.
My Favorite Bits: The Opening music/The showgirls outfits. Puttin’ on the Ritz. The way that the light on the elevator is the same height as the Dalek eye-stalk. Tallulah’s accent. “He’s into musical theater, huh?” The whole Busby Berkeley-esque dance routine. The Doctor realizing that the thing he found is genetically from Skaro. “They always survive when I lose everything.” “Yeah, well, you can kiss me later. You too Frank. If you want.”

Observations and musings:

Martha’s travels continue this week with a trip to 1930s New York. Wouldn’t you know it? This nice little trip to the past includes a visit to a Hooverville and Daleks. Luckily, Martha has been told about them (perhaps The Doctor is learning from past mistakes?) A young fella by the name of Frank seems to have taken a shine to her. Now, hopefully she’ll survive her encounter with those Daleks.

Once again The Doctor finds himself facing his oldest enemy, and he is not happy about this. “They always survive when I lose everything.” He turns a little Dark!Doctor there for a bit. He starts out curious about the missing people problem (not light hearted curious, but curious nonetheless), but once he discovers that there are Daleks involved…he takes it kind of personally. Actually, from the moment that he realizes that the thing he found in the tunnel is genetically from Skaro…well, he doesn’t go as dark as he did back in “Dalek,” but… Yeah. Is it Friday yet?

I love Tallulah (three “L”s and an “H.”) Um…does anyone else think that The Doctor could give The Professor from Gilligan’s Island a run for his money? You might say that Dalek Sec is thinking outside of the…pepper pot. I like Frank, and I hope that he survives. Poor Laszlo. What kind of future can he have with his showgirl now? The new Dalek Sec is a bit…weird looking, yeah? This episode is mostly designed to set up the next episode… Just wait and see, my friends.

, ,


4 Responses to “Review: Daleks in Manhattan (10th Doctor)”

  1. Erik Says:

    When he first pucked up the green thingie I yelled “It’s a baby Ruton!” and my non-Whovian visiting friend just stared at me.

  2. Elisa Says:

    Erik? You have non-Whovian friends?

    Convert! Convert!

    (Sorry, I got all Dalek-y there for a moment.)

  3. Erik Says:

    What the heck do you think I was doing?!?!?! ;-)

    I think I would have been more successful if it had been a stonger episode. Next time I’ll throw The Empty Child or Pyramids of Mars at him.

  4. Elisa Says:

    Or…Rose? Why not begin at the beginning?

    I’m starting out a friend that way. We’re halfway through the first season right now.

    Keep up the good work!

Leave a Reply


About Watching Doctor Who

Watching Doctor Who is a tale of obsession, an epic story of love and loss, a saga that spans time and space…Well, actually, it’s a blog that covers everything that has to do with the television show Doctor Who and its spin-offs. From news to videos and reviews to questions, you’ll find it here…and that other stuff, too.

Watching Doctor Who Author(s)

TV Channel Posts

  • A Couple of Suggestions for Your TV Viewing Tonight
    Monday night is such a great night to watch reality television and I just wanted to remind you all of what you could watch tonight. Last week MTV premiered the new season of Sex…with Mom and Dad. [...]
  • Double Duty
    Hello again! It’s Monday, new episode day! To tide you over until the show comes on, I’ve got a second promo for tonight to share. It was posted by Jonas Hodges. I actually really like this one [...]
  • ...But does the quilt travel in time?
    (It turns out that I've been collecting odds and ends of news and coolness in my Firefox tags since before I left for Gallifrey One. So, here they are all gathered together for you.) I've got [...]
  • Running Diary: 2009 Oscars
    ...And immediately we regret this decision. For a couple reasons, really. The aforementioned hangover and general fatigue is part of it, but we weren't all that enamored with most of the films with [...]
  • Watching the View Oscar Open Thread
    Feel free to comment about tonight's Academy Awards here! I look forward to seeing what role Whoopi Goldberg will be having in the ceremony and what her dress looks like. [...]
  • It’s an Amazing Race Reunion
    Ok so last week I told you about Reality Check Radio and that it basically rocked. In case you didn’t read my blog, although I am sure you all did, Reality Check Radio is an online BlogTalkRadio [...]
  • February 24, 2009 TV on DVD Releases: Animated
    Here is this week’s edition for TV on DVD Releases in the animated/kids category. Futurama: Into the Wild Green Yonder - This is a feature length film of the animated adult show, Futurama. It [...]
  • There's no place like Mode recap
    This week's episode of 'Ugly Betty' has the staff busy with Fashion Week and Betty with a new YETI assignment. Wilhemina works to get back on top in the fashion world as Daniel gives Molly as [...]
  • What's Coming Up On The CW?
    I've been wondering what's going on with the CW. It seems like there's been a lot of repeats lately, so I have nothing new to talk about. So I went through the next two weeks to see what's [...]
  • Sunday Posts
    Just a quick reminder that we're going to be live-blogging the Oscars tonight. We're tired, we're hungover and we have to sit in a high school audotorium for two hours here shortly, which will almost [...]

Hot Off The Press